AutoTrader Data Shows How Safety Ratings Help Dealers Close Used-Car Sales

Independent crash-test ratings can help dealers explain why one used vehicle may offer stronger value than another.

Price, mileage and brand familiarity still shape most used-car enquiries. Buyers know the badges they trust, they know roughly what they can afford, and they usually start by comparing similar cars on age, kilometres and monthly repayment.

Safety does not always lead the conversation, but it can change it. For dealers, a strong independent safety rating gives context to the price of a used vehicle, especially when a customer is comparing a familiar nameplate with another model that may offer stronger protection, newer technology or a better overall package.

AutoTrader data on used vehicles listed with five-star Euro NCAP safety ratings shows that safety-led stock is not confined to a narrow part of the market1. The models in the data include premium SUVs, executive cars, bakkies, hatchbacks and family crossovers, giving dealers several ways to bring safety into the sales conversation without making it feel forced.

Premium stock with a safety story

At the upper end of the market, the BMW X3 has 420 listings, an average price of R1,239,545 and average mileage of 10,174 km. Its average registration year places it close to the nearly new market, where buyers are often choosing between vehicles that are similar in terms of mileage and specification. In that space, a five-star safety rating supports the broader case for the vehicle, alongside technology, comfort and remaining warranty cover.

The Mercedes-Benz E-Class sits higher on price, with 23 listings, an average price of R1,493,595 and average mileage of 8,447 km. Buyers in this segment will expect a high level of safety, but the rating still matters because it gives the dealer a factual point to support what the badge already suggests. For buyers using the car for long-distance travel, executive transport or family use, that reassurance is part of the value.

The Omoda C9 gives dealers another premium SUV to position around safety. With 267 listings, an average price of R752,389 and average mileage of 5,830 km, it sits below the X3 and E-Class on average price, while still offering a five-star safety rating. That makes it a useful option for buyers who want a premium SUV but are also comparing price, equipment and brand familiarity.

The Volkswagen Tayron also fits into the family SUV conversation, with 81 listings, an average price of R828,081 and average mileage of 7,844 km. Its rating gives dealers another practical point to raise with buyers who are looking for space, comfort and a recognised badge, particularly where the vehicle is being bought for family use.

Safety is not only a premium message

The Ford Ranger is the clearest example of how safety can apply at scale. It appears with 7,593 listings, an average price of R715,889 and average mileage of 7,570 km. Given the Ranger’s presence in the used market, its five-star rating is more than a technical detail. It gives dealers another point to raise with private buyers, business users and fleets, alongside the usual bakkie priorities of load ability, towing capacity and everyday practicality.

The Volkswagen Golf 8 plays a different role. With 489 listings, an average price of R729,525 and average mileage of 9,771 km, it gives dealers a mainstream passenger car that can be sold on more than familiarity and driving appeal. For buyers who want a compact used car but are still thinking about family use, commuting and longer-term ownership, the safety rating is a useful addition to the conversation.

Together, the Ranger and Golf show that safety does not have to sit in a small corner of the showroom. It can be part of the way dealers talk about high-volume, recognisable stock that already attracts buyer interest.

Where family buyers may pay attention

Subaru’s Forester and Crosstrek also stand out in the data, largely because of their low average mileage. The Forester has 133 listings, an average price of R722,441 and average mileage of 2,898 km, while the Crosstrek has 27 listings, an average price of R627,917 and average mileage of 2,455 km.

Both models are likely to appeal to buyers who are already thinking beyond the monthly repayment. School runs, weekend trips, road conditions and long-term reliability all tend to form part of the Subaru buying conversation. The five-star safety rating fits naturally into that discussion, particularly when the vehicle is also relatively new and low-mileage.

The Jaecoo J7 SHS has 86 listings, an average price of R611,540 and average mileage of 5,493 km. It gives dealers a safety-led point in a growing SUV market where buyers are comparing newer products with more familiar alternatives. The rating helps dealers talk about the car on its own merits, rather than only on price or specification.

Popular cars are not always the safest cars

Some of South Africa’s best-selling new and used passenger cars are popular for good reason. They are familiar, affordable, easy to finance and well understood by buyers. That popularity, however, does not always tell the full safety story.

Recent Global NCAP results are a reminder of that. The outgoing Toyota Starlet received a zero-star adult occupant protection rating in #SaferCarsForAfrica testing, although Global NCAP noted that Toyota has since updated the model in South Africa with additional standard safety features, including side head and body airbags. The African-market Toyota Corolla Cross tested by Global NCAP received a two-star adult occupant protection rating. Both are well-known vehicles in South Africa, which makes the comparison relevant for dealers handling safety-conscious buyers1,2.

This does not mean dealers should turn safety into a negative sales tactic. It means they should be ready to explain the difference between popularity, equipment levels and independent crash-test performance. A buyer may know a model well, but may not know how it has performed in a safety test, or how that compares with another vehicle at a similar price point.

Turning the safety angle into a listing advantage

The data also shows why safety should not be treated as a generic line in the listing. The same five-star rating will not do the same job on every vehicle.

On a BMW X3, Mercedes-Benz E-Class or Omoda C9, it supports the premium positioning and helps justify the price against other high-end used options. On a Ford Ranger, it adds reassurance to a vehicle already bought for work, lifestyle and family use. On a Volkswagen Golf, it gives dealers a stronger argument for buyers who want a compact car but still care about daily usability and protection. On the Subaru Forester and Crosstrek, it fits naturally with the family and lifestyle buyer who may already be thinking about long-distance travel, road conditions and children in the back seat.

That is where better listing data, stronger vehicle descriptions and more useful imagery can help dealers turn a safety credential into a clearer value message for buyers.

AutoTrader Intelligence – Comments Generator can help dealers shape that message using the information already supplied in the listing, making it easier to surface relevant selling points without writing every description from scratch. For a Ranger, that might mean pairing safety with everyday practicality and business use. For a Forester, it might mean linking the rating to family use and low mileage. For a premium SUV, it can help keep the safety message aligned with comfort, technology and specification.

AutoTrader Intelligence – Image Management also becomes more relevant when the safety angle is tied to a use case. A family-focused listing needs clean interior images, rear-seat visibility, boot space and feature details. A premium listing needs the comfort and technology cues that support its price. A bakkie listing needs the practical images that show condition, load area and cabin usability. The better the image set, the easier it is for the buyer to understand the vehicle before making contact.

AutoTrader Intelligence – Dealer Insights then helps dealers keep the safety-led value argument grounded in the live market. A five-star rating may strengthen the case for a car, but it does not protect an overpriced listing. Dealer Insights gives dealers visibility into demand, supply and pricing trends at the listing level, helping them understand whether the vehicle’s price matches the market it is competing in.

“Safety is becoming a more important part of the value equation in the used-car market, not because buyers have stopped caring about price, mileage or brand, but because they are asking better questions about what those things really mean,” said George Mienie, CEO of AutoTrader. 

“For dealers, this is where data becomes powerful. It allows them to move the conversation beyond assumption and familiarity, and towards evidence. A popular car is not automatically the safest choice, and a premium car is not automatically the best value. The opportunity for dealers is to help customers understand those differences clearly, using the market data and vehicle information available to them. That is how trust is built, and in a more competitive market, trust is what ultimately turns interest into a decision,” added Mienie.

What dealers can take from the data

The value of a five-star safety rating is not that it replaces price, mileage, condition or service history. Those factors still matter. Its value is that it gives dealers another factual point to use when a buyer is deciding between similar cars.

For premium SUVs and executive cars, it supports the price and specification story. For vehicles such as the Ranger and Golf, it adds weight to models that already have strong recognition in the used market. For Subaru’s family-focused models, it fits naturally with the way buyers think about daily use and long-term ownership. For newer SUV entrants, it gives dealers a credible way to discuss the vehicle beyond equipment levels and monthly repayment.

That is where safety is most useful at the dealership. It helps sales teams ask better questions about how the vehicle will be used, who will travel in it and what else the buyer is considering. It also gives dealers a stronger basis for explaining why one used vehicle may offer better value than another, even when the more familiar car looks easier to choose at first.

AutoTrader Used Car Data

Source: AutoTrader Used Car Sales Data: 1 January 2025 – 31 April 2026

Sources: 

1. https://www.euroncap.com/assessments/?assessmentType.code=CAR_SAFETY&limit=20&path=%2Fassessments&sort=protocol.protocolYear%3Adesc%2Cmake.name%3Aasc 
2. https://www.globalncap.org/news/zero-stars-for-outgoing-version-of-toyota-starlet
3. https://aa.co.za/aa-raises-deep-concerns-as-toyota-corolla-cross-scores-two-stars-for-adult-protection-in-africa/ 

CLICK HERE to submit your press release to MyPR.co.za.

Proceed to Page 2 for Contact Info and Editor’s Notes.

Read More at MyPR.co.za

Tell-Em Public Relations (EA) Ltd: Public relations firm Tell-Em Public Relations (EA) Ltd is based in Nairobi, Kenya. Launched in
1999, the team provides Public Relations and Digital Strategy.