Dear Editor
The Democratic Alliance (DA) in the Eastern Cape has raised serious concerns regarding the socio-economic implications of relocating the main seat of the Eastern Cape Division of the High Court from Makhanda to Bhisho. This proposal risks exacerbating the economic challenges Makhanda’s residents and the broader Eastern Cape community face.
Recent responses from the Justice Minister to parliamentary questions posed by the DA’s EC NCOP delegate, Henni Brits, shed light on the critical need for more thoughtful consideration of the proposal’s impact. While the distinction between a “relocation” and a “re-designation” has been highlighted, this does little to address the underlying economic and social consequences that such a move will have.
Any rationale for the proposed move must be balanced against the potential loss of over 5,000 direct jobs in Makhanda and the ripple effects on 25,000 dependents.
Such a move could have severe repercussions for an already fragile local economy, undermining livelihoods and destabilising the municipality.
We understand that growth and development might require unpopular decisions. We also understand that sometimes difficult decisions must be made to ensure progress. However, the proposed move of the prestigious seat of the High Court in Makhanda to Bhisho does not equate to progress, growth, or better access to justice. It is not just an inconvenient decision. It is a catastrophic proposal that threatens to devastate a core institution of our province.
Furthermore, the assertion that the move would improve access to justice is questionable. Bhisho is no more accessible to many rural communities in the Eastern Cape than Makhanda. The infrastructural challenges and economic barriers these communities face require holistic interventions, not simply shifting from one town to another.
The requirement for public participation in the amendment to the Superior Courts Act presents significant opportunities for stakeholders to engage in robust discussions, although limited.
The DA encourages legal fraternity, business community, and civil society members to continue advocating for solutions that preserve jobs, protect economic stability, and improve access to justice across the province.
We also call for engagements beyond the anticipated public participation in the required legislative amendments to affect the relocation. The DA will intensify our efforts within the legislature to ensure that all aspects of this proposed change are given due consideration.
We remain committed to amplifying the concerns raised regarding the socio-economic impact of this relocation within the legislature, working to ensure that decisions prioritise the needs of all Eastern Cape residents.
The DA will continue championing sustainable solutions that foster economic resilience and enhance the justice system without compromising communities. The fight to protect Makhanda’s economy and its people is far from over, and we stand united in seeking alternatives that work for the entire Eastern Cape.
Regards
Dr Vicky Knoetze MPL
DA Leader of the Official Opposition in the Eastern Cape Legislature
Freeze Queen
Did you knowthis about South Africa? South Africa celebrates its annual Heritage Day on 24 September. On this day, South Africans get together to celebrate their diverse cultures, traditions and beliefs. You’ll most likely find people enjoying a braai (barbecue) and dressed in traditional garb.
Kill Switch
Bobotie – a spicy mince dish [buh-boor-tee] This delicious dish originated in Malay cooking and is made with spicy minced meat, baked in the oven with an egg custard topping. It is usually served with yellow rice and raisins.