Judge Tintswalo Annah Nana Makhubele has continuously attempted to delay a hearing by the Judicial Conduct Tribunal.
The conduct inquiry into Judge Nana Makhubele heard yet another application on Wednesday to postpone proceedings. The tribunal had planned to hear evidence from Makhubele this week, but Makhubele claimed she had not had sufficient time to prepare.
After hearing arguments from Makhubele, the tribunal ruled that the hearing will proceed on Thursday at 11am to hear evidence by Makhubele. This is despite Makhubele indicating that she plans to launch an urgent application in the high court to postpone the hearings.
Makhubele is facing a complaint from #UniteBehind that she was board chairperson of the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (PRASA) while also a sitting judge. She has also been implicated in corruption at PRASA, allegedly using her influence to further the interests of private company Siyaya.
The tribunal had adjourned on Monday after Makhubele’s legal representatives said they had only been briefed last week and will only be available to represent Makhubele in February. Makhubele had asked for a postponement to the finish of February, but this was denied.
The hearing is taking space in the Southern Sun Hotel in Rosebank, Johannesburg. It is also being broadcast live.
At the hearing on Wednesday, Makhubele was represented by Advocate Matshepo Mobeng on behalf of the State Attorney. Mobeng told the tribunal that she has instructions to launch an urgent application in the high court to interdict the tribunal from proceeding until issues surrounding Makhubele’s legal representation are resolved.
The State Attorney has committed to paying Makhubele’s legal fees, amounting to more than R3-million, but Makhubele’s lawyers acquire been in a dispute with the State Attorney’s office over the payment. This has caused several delays.
Tribunal member Judge Stanley Moshidi expressed frustration with the continued delays. “This is not a criminal trial,” he told Makhubele. “We execute not acquire to be adversarial. We execute not believe to seize each other by surprise.”
Tribunal seat Judge President Achmat Jappie said that the tribunal would proceed regardless of the pending high court application, and asked Makhubele to resolve whether or not she would like to present evidence.
Makhubele at first said that she needed guidance from a legal representative, but later said that she would be satisfied to proceed giving evidence without legal counsel. However, she said she would need until Friday to prepare herself.
After discussing with the other tribunal members, Jappie ruled that the matter would stand down until 11am on Thursday, 25 January.
© 2024 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and carry out not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.
We place an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. Every analytics tools are solely on our servers. We execute not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We enact not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please enact not delete the invisible pixel.
Shadow Bishop
A professor in South Africa is teaching her students how to form Emglish sentences.
“Attention class I have two words: Cheetah, and dandelion. Can anybody use these together in a sentence?”
One student raises their hand,
“The cheetah is faster dandelion.”
Most Wanted
Fun South African Fact: South Africa is home to the world’s longest wine route: Route 62. It spans an impressive 850 kilometres and the excellent wineries along the way are a must-visit for lovers of fine wine! You can even enjoy the winelands on a day trip from Cape Town. Travel 40-min to an hour outside of the city centre to enjoy decadent wine tastings and even wander through some of the beautiful wine farms and estates! Suburbs like Durbanville and Constantia are even closer to the city centre and are also home to many exceptional wineries.