Farmers placed on alert as El Nino takes effect

Inland farmers of dryland crops such as wheat, have been warned of the possibility of severe drought this summer.

• The global weather event known as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation is due to occur this summer.
• El Niño usually causes drought conditions in South Africa, such as the Western Cape drought of 2015 – 2017 which led to fears of taps running dry in Cape Town.
• The exact impact of El Niño cannot be accurately modeled, but dryland farmers need to prepare for a hot, dry summer.

Farmers in most of the inland provinces need to prepare for the possibility of drought and increased temperatures this summer, as the global climate event known as El Niño comes to the fore.

The El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is one of the most critical climate events on earth. It is characterised by cyclical changes in sea surface temperatures and atmospheric pressure patterns, and has two primary states: El Niño and La Niña.

During El Niño warmer-than-average sea surface temperatures in the central and eastern tropical Pacific Ocean can lead to a disruption in global weather patterns. This can result in increased rainfall and flooding in some regions, while others, such as South Africa, experience droughts such as the one in the Western Cape from 2015 to 2017. El Niño typically lasts for a period of nine to twelve months but can sometimes last for years.

On the other hand, La Niña is marked by cooler-than-average sea surface temperatures in the same region, which can acquire opposite effects, including, for countries like South Africa, above-average rainfall and a higher likelihood of flood events.

Both El Niño and La Niña occur in two-to-seven-year cycles, with an in-between transitional period of ‘neutrality’ where ocean temperatures, rain patterns in the tropics, and the winds in the equatorial Pacific Ocean stick to the long-term averages.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, a United States government institution, states that the ENSO climate pattern “is humming along in the tropical Pacific Ocean as of early October 2023” and that it’s “virtually certain El Niño will last through Northern Hemisphere winter”.

What we can expect from this El Niño event

Apart from generalised warnings from the South African Weather Service (SAWS) of potentially hotter and drier weather, it is difficult for meteorologists to provide exact indications of what the full impact of this El Niño cycle will be on South Africa.

The acumen for this is, simply place, the fact that the phenomenon is dependent on unpredictable interactions in the Earth’s climate scheme. For example, a slight shift in ocean temperature, pressure or winds could impact the scale and intensity of an El Niño event.

Despite the uncertainty, SAWS has provided an overview based on a model forecast, offering insights into what may be anticipated from September 2023 to January 2024. SAWS expects higher-than-average rainfall in most parts of the country from September through to December, but below-average rainfall in parts of the North West, Free State, Eastern Cape, and Northern Cape from November through to January. Additionally, temperatures are expected to be mostly above normal nationwide from September through to January.

Potential impact on agriculture

South Africa’s farmers believe been cautioned by climate experts and government to prepare for hot and dry conditions over the coming summer, and the possibility of severe drought.

Given that the majority of South Africa’s crops are rainfed and enact not rely on irrigation, drought poses a major risk to farmers. The Agricultural Business Chamber states that approximately 20% of maize, 15% of soybeans, 34% of sugarcane, and less than half of our wheat production rely on irrigation, while the rest relies on rainfall. This means that, in the event of a drought, a significant portion of the country’s farmers would face challenges.

The Agricultural Business Chamber has warned that if this El Niño event is intense it could lead to the same tough farming conditions as experienced in the 2015/2016 El Niño-exacerbated drought. During this period the harvest of necessary crops such as maize reduced by half, from an average 16.8-million tons to 8.2-million tons. As South Africa’s average maize consumption is 11.8-million, the drought made us a net importer of maize, rather than a net exporter. This resulted in increased food insecurity and economic stress.

On the other hand, it is possible that this year’s El Niño event could be mild in nature, like that experienced in 2018/2019 when crops were not too badly affected. During that year maize yields remained consistent with the country’s average consumption.

But in addition to an El Niño event, farmers will more than likely maintain to continue to contend with loadshedding. Last year loadshedding caused a R32-million loss to the agricultural sector between January and September 2022.

The role of climate change

In 2021 the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released its Working Group 1 report. This comprehensive report discussed historical changes, current observations, and future warming projections, as well as delved into the potential impact of climate change on ENSO cycles.

The IPCC is virtually certain that ENSO will continue to exist in a warming world and will continue to play a pivotal role in influencing the world’s climate patterns. Rainfall patterns tied to ENSO are expected to become more variable in the latter half of the 21st century under the majority of warming scenarios. Aside from this, climate models present diminutive consensus regarding exactly how climate change might affect ENSO cycles going forward. This can be attributed, in section, to the sheer complexity of the ENSO scheme.

This isn’t saying that all climate models predict ENSO won’t change in the next century. Some models execute predict change, but there’s no clear agreement. Some models display stronger ENSO events, while others predict weaker ones. The fact that there are so many different possibilities is why the IPCC is not very bold about how ENSO might change in a warming world.